When a Letter of Demand Isn’t Enough
You’ve followed up, sent a letter of demand and given your customer every chance to pay. If they still haven’t paid — or haven’t even responded — it may be time to take the matter to court.
For many business owners, “going to court” sounds expensive and intimidating. In reality, NSW has a structured, step-by-step process for recovering debts, and many claims are resolved without a hearing ever taking place.
This is Part 2 of our three-part Debt Recovery series where we focus on Statement of Claim.
It explains how to choose the right NSW court, file and serve a statement of claim, obtain default judgment and what happens if the debtor defends the claim. If you haven’t yet sent a letter of demand, start with Part 1.
Before You File: Three Questions to Answer
1. Who exactly are you suing? Your claim must name the correct legal entity. If you dealt with a company, you sue the company (using its name and ACN), not its director — unless the director signed a personal guarantee. If you dealt with a sole trader, you sue the individual, not their business name. Partnerships and trusts have their own rules.
2. Is it commercially worth it? Consider the size of the debt, the likely legal costs, how much of those costs you can recover, and whether the debtor has income or assets to pay a judgment. Court proceedings make the most sense when the debt is clear, the amount is significant and the debtor can pay.
3. What can you claim on top of the debt? As well as the principal amount, you may be able to claim:
- interest — either under your terms of trade or, if there’s no contractual rate, interest up to judgment under section 100 of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW)
- filing and service fees
- legal costs, subject to the court’s costs rules.
💡 Tip: Before filing, run an ASIC search on a company debtor. If it’s already deregistered or in liquidation, court proceedings may not be the right path.
Choosing the Right NSW Court
In NSW, the court that hears your claim depends on how much you’re owed.
| Amount owed | Court |
|---|---|
| Up to $20,000 | Local Court — Small Claims Division |
| Over $20,000 up to $100,000 | Local Court — General Division (up to $120,000 if the parties agree) |
| Over $100,000 up to $1,250,000 | District Court of NSW |
| Over $1,250,000 | Supreme Court of NSW |
Source: Legal Aid NSW.
Most business debts in regional NSW fall within the Local Court’s jurisdiction, and claims can be heard at the Local Court in Kempsey.
The Small Claims Division is designed to be quick and informal. The rules of evidence don’t strictly apply, and the legal costs a successful party can recover are capped. The General Division is more formal, with stricter procedures — but costs aren’t capped in the same way.
Some disputes, particularly consumer claims about goods and services, can also be heard by the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT). An NCAT money order must be registered with the Local Court before it can be enforced.
Filing and Serving a Statement of Claim
Debt recovery proceedings in NSW start with a statement of claim, prepared on the approved form under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW). It sets out:
- the plaintiff (you) and the defendant (the debtor)
- how the debt arose — for example, goods supplied or services provided under an agreement
- the amount claimed, plus any interest and costs.
The statement of claim can be filed online through the NSW Online Registry or at a court registry, and a filing fee is payable.
Once filed, it must be served on the debtor so they know about the claim. Depending on the court and the debtor, it may be served personally, by post, or by the court registry posting it to the debtor. Service must follow the rules carefully — improper service is one of the most common reasons default judgment applications fail. A statement of claim is generally only valid for service for a limited time after it’s filed, so it’s important to serve it promptly.
💡 Tip: The statement of claim includes a notice telling the debtor what happens if they don’t respond. Receiving it is often the moment debtors finally pay.
The Debtor’s 28 Days and Default Judgment
Under rule 14.3 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), a defendant has 28 days after being served with a statement of claim to file a defence. Within that time, the debtor can:
- pay the amount claimed (including interest and costs), which ends the matter
- admit the debt and ask to pay it by instalments
- file a defence disputing all or part of the claim, or
- do nothing.
If the debtor does nothing, you can apply to the court for default judgment once the 28 days have passed. This is a judgment entered in your favour without a hearing. To obtain it, you’ll generally need to show the debtor was properly served, the 28 days have expired, and no defence has been filed or payment made.
There’s also a deadline on your side. Legal Aid NSW notes you have nine months from filing the statement of claim to apply for default judgment.
A debtor who missed the deadline may later apply to have a default judgment set aside — usually by showing a good reason for the delay and a genuine defence. That’s another reason why getting service right matters.
If the Debtor Files a Defence
A defence means the debtor disputes the claim, and the matter moves into the court’s case management process.
In the Small Claims Division, the first step is usually a pre-trial review. A Registrar meets with both parties and tries to help them settle. If the matter doesn’t settle, the court sets a timetable for each side to file written statements and documents, then lists it for hearing before a Magistrate or assessor.
In the General Division, the process is more formal. There may be directions hearings, disclosure of documents, affidavit evidence and, in many cases, mediation before a hearing.
At any stage, the parties can settle — for example, by agreeing to a reduced lump sum or a payment schedule. Any settlement should be documented in writing, and the court can make consent orders to finalise the matter.
What about legal costs? The general rule is that the losing party pays a portion of the winner’s legal costs. In the Small Claims Division, the costs you can recover are capped. In the General Division, costs aren’t capped in the same way, but you won’t usually recover every dollar you spend.
💡 Tip: A debtor’s defence can sometimes reveal a genuine issue with the work or goods supplied. Early legal advice helps you decide whether to push on, negotiate or settle.
Mistakes to Avoid in Court Proceedings
- Naming the wrong defendant. A judgment against the wrong person or entity can’t be enforced against the real debtor.
- Filing in the wrong court or division. Claiming more than a court’s limit, or splitting one debt into smaller claims to fit a lower limit, causes delay and extra cost.
- Getting service wrong. Defective service can lead to a default judgment being set aside.
- Missing the deadline for default judgment. Leaving it too long after filing can mean starting again.
- Under-preparing your evidence. If the debtor defends the claim, you’ll need invoices, terms of trade, correspondence and proof of delivery ready to go.
- Refusing to negotiate. A reasonable settlement offer can save months of time and cost — and an unreasonable refusal can affect the costs the court orders.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which court do I use to recover a debt in NSW? Claims up to $20,000 go to the Local Court’s Small Claims Division, and claims over $20,000 up to $100,000 go to its General Division. Larger claims are heard in the District Court or the Supreme Court.
How long does the debtor have to respond to a statement of claim? Under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), the debtor generally has 28 days after service to file a defence.
What is default judgment? It’s a judgment entered in your favour, without a hearing, when the debtor doesn’t file a defence or pay within the time allowed.
Do I need a lawyer for the Small Claims Division? No, many people represent themselves. However, a lawyer can make sure the claim is against the right party, properly prepared and correctly served — which avoids delays and the risk of a judgment being set aside.
Can I recover my legal costs if I win? Usually some of them. In the Small Claims Division, recoverable costs are capped. In the General Division, you can usually recover a larger portion, but rarely all of your costs.
What happens after I get judgment? If the debtor still doesn’t pay, you can enforce the judgment through options such as garnishee orders and writs. We explain these in Part 3.
Ready to Take Action? Talk to Sheridan Legal
Court proceedings don’t have to be daunting. Sheridan Legal acts for businesses across Kempsey, South West Rocks and the Mid North Coast in debt recovery claims in the NSW Local Court and beyond.
We can:
- check the debtor’s details and confirm the correct party to sue
- prepare, file and serve your statement of claim
- apply for default judgment when the debtor doesn’t respond
- represent you at pre-trial reviews and hearings if the claim is defended
- negotiate settlements and document them properly.
Not sure if your debt is worth taking to court? Book a short 10-minute call with Patrick Sheridan for a practical assessment of your options.
👉 Find out more about our Debt Recovery services
📞 Call Kempsey on (02) 6562 3300 or South West Rocks on (02) 6566 6250, or visit our Book an Appointment page.
This article is part of our 3-part series on Debt Recovery. Read our other articles here:
- Part 1 – Unpaid Invoices? How to Recover a Debt in NSW Before Going to Court
- Part 3 – Enforcing a Judgment Debt in NSW: How to Actually Get Paid
This article provides general information only and is not legal advice. Please contact us for advice about your specific circumstances.
